Railroad worker law

FELA vs. Workers’ Comp: Why Railroaders Don’t File Comp Claims

Last updated 21 June 2026

If you are hurt working for a railroad, you almost never file a workers’ compensation claim. Instead you bring a claim under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act (FELA), 45 U.S.C. §51. Here is the practical difference and why it usually matters enormously to what an injury is worth.

Informational only. This page provides general legal information, not legal advice. TrainAccidentLawyer.us is not a law firm and no attorney–client relationship is created by reading it. FELA cases turn on their specific facts and on current law; consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction before acting.

Bottom line: Workers’ comp is no-fault but capped. FELA is fault-based but uncapped. Because FELA allows full tort damages — including pain and suffering and lost future earnings — the same injury is typically worth far more under FELA than under a state comp schedule.

Why railroad workers are excluded from workers’ comp

When Congress passed FELA in 1908, railroading was among the deadliest jobs in America. Rather than fold railroaders into the state workers’ compensation systems that emerged soon after, Congress kept them under a federal negligence law. That is why, to this day, a covered railroad employee’s exclusive remedy against the employer for an on-duty injury is FELA — not comp.

Side-by-side comparison

	Workers’ Compensation	FELA (45 U.S.C. §51)
Must prove fault?	No (no-fault)	Yes — but a very low “featherweight” bar
Pain & suffering	Not recoverable	Fully recoverable
Lost future earnings	Limited, scheduled	Full, uncapped
Who sets the value	State benefit schedule	Negotiation or a jury
Where claims are decided	Administrative agency	State or federal court
Deadline to file	Varies by state	3 years (45 U.S.C. §56)

The trade-off: proof for value

Comp pays quickly and predictably without proving anyone did anything wrong, but it bars pain and suffering and pays scheduled amounts that rarely reflect a serious career-ending injury. FELA demands that you show the railroad’s negligence played some part in your injury — but under the Supreme Court’s decision in Rogers v. Missouri Pacific R. Co. (1957), that causation bar is famously low: the railroad is liable if its negligence contributed “in whole or in part,” even slightly.

Who is covered by FELA

Employees of interstate railroads (engineers, conductors, brakemen, maintenance-of-way, signal, shop, and yard workers)
Injuries that occur while engaged in the railroad’s interstate-commerce work
Occupational diseases from cumulative on-the-job exposure (e.g., hearing loss, toxic exposure)

Transit and commuter-rail workers may instead be covered by state comp or other statutes depending on the employer — a fact-specific question worth confirming with counsel.

What this means for the value of a claim

Because FELA opens the door to the full spectrum of tort damages, well-documented FELA recoveries are frequently a multiple of what the same injury would yield under comp. See our FELA damages guide for the categories you can recover, and our settlement averages guide for how injury severity drives ranges.

Do railroad workers get workers' comp?

Generally no. Covered railroad employees are excluded from state workers' compensation and instead bring claims under FELA (45 U.S.C. §51), a fault-based federal law that allows full tort damages including pain and suffering.

Is FELA better than workers' comp?

It depends. FELA requires proving the railroad's negligence played some part in the injury, but in exchange it allows uncapped damages — including pain and suffering and lost future earning capacity — that comp does not. For serious injuries, FELA is usually far more valuable.

What is the FELA burden of proof?

FELA uses a 'featherweight' causation standard from Rogers v. Missouri Pacific R. Co. (1957): the railroad is liable if its negligence contributed to the injury 'in whole or in part,' even slightly — a much lower bar than ordinary negligence.

How long do I have to file a FELA claim?

Three years from the date of injury, or from when you knew or should have known a condition was work-related, under 45 U.S.C. §56. Missing the deadline permanently bars the claim.

Related FELA & railroad-injury guides

Reviewed by the TrainAccidentLawyer.us editorial team

Published by Mustafa Bilgic. Our guides are written for general education and fact-checked against primary U.S. sources — the Federal Railroad Administration, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, and the text of the Federal Employers’ Liability Act (45 U.S.C. §§51–60). We cite institutions, not anonymous “experts.” This page is informational and is not legal advice.

See how FELA changes the numbers

Choose “Railroad worker (FELA)” in the calculator to compare a FELA-style outcome against a capped comp schedule.

Estimate my FELA case